This site may load slowly at times because of the numerous images. Please reload the page if some of the images do not appear. Thank you.

Search This Site

History Opinion Poll: "Have Western Historians Under-emphasized The Role Of Russia In Defeating Nazi Germany?"





Rodric Braithwaite, ambassador to Moscow in the 1960s and again during perestroika, argues that the battle of Moscow is one of the most overlooked moments in history. Fighting over a territory the size of France, more than 900,000 Soviet soldiers died, a figure that exceeds the combined deaths of the British and American forces in the Second World War. For every Briton or American who died, the Soviets lost 85 people.

Braithwaite concludes that 'had they not been fighting the Russians, they would have been in France, and there would have been no D-Day'.


What do you think? Do you feel that historians, especially those from the West have not underlined the fact that if Russia had collapsed in 1941/42, the Allies would never have been able to defeat Hitlerite Germany. That the Russians have not been given due recognition for defeating the once invincible German army during World War Two.

The result....
Total Votes Cast: 130
YES: 74%
NO: 26%

Share this PostPin ThisShare on TumblrShare on Google PlusEmail This

9 Comments:

Anonymous said...

Russia bore the brunt and lost in one month what the americans or british lost during the whole war. Stalin caused this by not acknowledging the millions of tons of lend lease material from the US, Canada and UK. The resentment still carries.

Anonymous said...

I suspect that we would have won regardless but the price would have been tripled or quadrupled. Let's not forget the Russian winter. US and western technology would have won but when and at what cost? I do believe that Russia was left to take the brunt of the force, and that crossing the channel should have been accomplished in 1943. Many more variables but Russia did get the short stick.

The Sanity Inspector said...

Western historians gave the Soviet Union plenty of credit. Or tried to: The secretive, dissembling nature of Soviet communism made it hard to get accurate facts. Plus, the Soviets kept repeating that Western historians were denying credit to the USSR, which was not the case. The Western historians were much more fair and accurate than the lapdog Soviet academics.

pinnock said...

Thank God for the poor roads that were so muddied during the winters in Russia, helping to bog down the Germans. Also the extreme cold for which the Germans were ill prepared. If the Russians had not been effective the end would still have come for Hitler cos after the dropping of the A-bombs in Japan, what was to stop Truman from levelling Berlin?

Anonymous said...

I think they get too much credit, to be honest. Hitler had more to do with the Germans defeat, than Russia. I dont know how anyone can say otherwise.

mdgiles said...

It was the 1939 Non-Aggression Pact between The USSR and Nazi Germany, that allowed the war to start in the first place. By making that pack, it allowed the Nazis to eliminate the Soviet's potential allies in the West, and then the Nazis turned on them. If the Allies had treated the Russians as the Russians had treated them, they would have made a separate peace with the Nazis and left the Russians to fight them on their own.

Anonymous said...

They got what they deserved,at the end the germans got of light they should of pay a heavier price for what they did.

Anonymous said...

The germans followed hitler to hell they got what they deserved.

Ali Ihsan Celebi said...

Without Russia 1 million or so German soldiers would've flattened Britain, there would be no normandy and no further obstacle for Germany to solidify their victory in Europe and Britain. Effectively world would had to accept the fact and war would end here, or Germany could replendish their troops before moving on.

Post a Comment

You Might Like These....

Search This Site

Popular Articles On This Site

More History Sites

Illustrated History

A Lousy Journalist?

A Lousy Journalist?
"Those who do not remember the past are condemned to repeat it."
-- George Santayana


History Quotes

May 1945 - If hell on earth existed, than it existed in Prague after May the 5th. 1945. Old men, women and children were beaten to death and maimed. Rapes, barbaric cruelties, horror-scenarios of hellish proportions - here they had been let lose.

- Ludek Pachmann, Czech Chess-Grand Master and publicist, forty years after the fact.

Copyright Issue

All the images on this site have been uploaded from the internet. Their copyrights lie with the respective owners.

If inadvertently any copy-righted material is published on this site, the owners of the material may contact us at balri24@gmail.com. We will remove the relevant portion immediately

Quotes

"History is a guide to navigation in perilous times. History is who we are and why we are the way we are."
-- DAVID C. MCCULLOUGH

History, despite its wrenching pain, cannot be unlived, but if faced with courage, need not be lived again.
-- MARY ANGELOU

Quotes

HISTORY, n. An account mostly false, of events mostly unimportant, which are brought about by rulers mostly knaves, and soldiers mostly fools.
-- Ambrose Bierce

We learn from history that we learn nothing from history.
-- GEORGE BERNARD SHAW

Quotes

"I have but one lamp by which my feet are guided, and that is the lamp of experience. I know no way of judging of the future but by the past."
--EDWARD GIBBON

"Patriotism ruins history."
-- GOETHE

Snippets from History

This short but important battle played a key role in the decision to use atomic bombs when attacking Hiroshima and Nagasaki. The battle showed just how far Japanese troops would go to defend their country.


Snippets From History

Paulus didn't give the order to 6th Army to surrender, but his troops no longer had much fight left in them. Resistance faded out over the next two days, with the last die-hards finally calling it quits. One Red Army colonel shouted at a group of prisoners, waving at the ruins all around them: "That's how Berlin is going to look!
"



Quotes

History is Philosophy teaching by examples.
-- THUCYDIDES

Quotes

"Those who cannot learn from history are doomed to repeat it."
-- George Santayana

Points to Ponder: Why Is China Unstable?

The aim of individuals in any society is money and power. Societies that give equal chance to all its members to get them will be the most stable. That is why democracies are more stable than other systems of governance.

China after Deng's reform gave the chance to get rich but power is in the hands of an elite; the Communist Party of China. Membership to the party is at the whims of the local party bosses. This leaves out many people who crave political power dissatisfied and disgruntled. There in lies the roots of instability. The Party suppressed these demands once at Tiananmen in 1989. But force is hardly the way to deal with things like these.

READ MORE: Tiananmen Square Massacre